Levocetirizine Equal to Cetirizine in Sedation, Efficacy


December 6, 2011 — Unacceptable sedation with antihistamines is a standard purpose why sufferers cease taking their medicines, however the first blinded placebo-controlled trial to check levocetirizine and cetirizine has discovered that levocetirizine didn’t show much less sedating and had no added efficacy. Sufferers who beforehand reported somnolence with cetirizine tolerated levocetirizine, however the trial additionally means that many sufferers would even have been capable of tolerate cetirizine in the event that they have been masked. The analysis was printed within the December challenge of the Annals of Allergy, Bronchial asthma, and Immunology.

Douglas B. Tzanetos, MD, from Allergy and Bronchial asthma Physicians of Central Kentucky in Lexington, and colleagues from Vanderbilt College in Nashville, Tennessee, enrolled 30 sufferers with persistent allergic rhinitis between January 28, 2009, and February 25, 2009. All had beforehand reported important somnolence with cetirizine, outlined as being both not having the ability to tolerate the drug or capable of tolerate both a 5-mg dose of cetirizine or a 10-mg dose of cetirizine solely at evening due to self-reported daytime somnolence. Earlier analysis urged that levocetirizine is much less sedating than cetirizine, and that 2.5 mg of levocetirizine is equal to five mg of cetirizine. levocetirizine is the R-enantiomer of cetirizine, and the investigators hypothesized that it will be stronger.

In randomized order, with washout intervals between therapies, sufferers got 5 mg every day levocetirizine, 10 mg every day cetirizine, or the same placebo capsule for 1 week every, with a 5-day washout interval earlier than transferring to the subsequent remedy. Though 30 sufferers have been enrolled, 29 sufferers accomplished the examine. One affected person was excluded from the evaluation as a result of she didn’t return a examine questionnaire. Sufferers didn’t know which capsule they have been taking. Sleepiness was evaluated with the Epworth Sleepiness Scale (ESS), a Likert scale developed by the researchers, and a complete rhinitis symptom rating.

Preliminary qualitative outcomes from the ESS revealed that 11 sufferers ranked cetirizine as probably the most sedating, 6 ranked levocetirizine as probably the most sedating, and 6 ranked placebo as probably the most sedating. The remaining sufferers ranked 1 or extra therapies equally. The Likert scale findings confirmed that 11 sufferers ranked cetirizine as probably the most sedating, 5 sufferers thought-about levocetirizine to be probably the most sedating, and three ranked the placebo as probably the most sedating.

Sedation, Efficacy Ranked the Similar Subjectively

Utilizing the ESS, sedation was the identical within the levocetirizine group (imply, 6.69; SD, 4.05) vs within the cetirizine group (imply, 7.48; SD, 5.31; P = .52). The Likert scores additionally confirmed no important variations in somnolence between the levocetirizine (imply, 3.07; SD, 1.92) and the cetirizine (imply, 3.54; SD, 2.17; P = .42) teams. Even a subgroup evaluation of the 16 sufferers who discontinued cetirizine as a result of they discovered sleepiness insupportable didn’t present a big distinction on the ESS (imply, 7.29 for cetirizine vs 6.86 for levocetirizine; P = .78). In truth, no important variations have been discovered on any scales. Efficacy was related on the full rhinitis symptom rating (imply, 3.14; SD, 2.67) vs cetirizine (imply, 2.67; SD, 2.44; P = .45).

The authors weren’t fast to embrace their findings, noting that the trial’s displaying that “levocetirizine was neither much less sedating nor more practical than cetirizine is likely to be partially because of the small pattern measurement, particularly in regard to the ESS, and thus the examine might have been underpowered to detect a small however true distinction.”

They add: “It’s attainable that the small variations in sedation between the teams with the big variation in responses as indicated by the comparatively giant commonplace deviations of the variations…might have obscured a real distinction.”

The examine was supported by a Vanderbilt College Medical and Translational Science Award grant from the Nationwide Middle for Analysis Sources of the Nationwide Institutes of Well being. The authors have disclosed no related monetary relationships.

Ann Allergy Bronchial asthma Immunol. 2011;107:517-522. Summary


Supply hyperlink