College students Set to Seem for CA Exams Query ICAI’s Selections


New Delhi: The Chartered Accountancy Exams scheduled to be held between November 21 and December 14 this 12 months have left dozens of scholars in a lurch about their future as they fear if they are going to be capable of attain the examination centres amid security issues in the course of the pandemic.

The exams, performed by the ICAI (Institute of Chartered Accountants of India) happen twice yearly, in Could and November, respectively. Nonetheless, this 12 months, owing to the COVID-19 pandemic, the exams scheduled to be held in Could have been postponed a number of instances and merged with the November exams.

Picture: Particular Association

The CA examinations are thought-about one of many hardest exams on the earth, with an exceptionally low cross share of about 10%.

Dhruv Gehlot, a closing 12 months pupil at Jodhpur College, Rajasthan informed The Wire that his CA examination try was due in Could however was merged with November 2020 examination attributable to COVID-19. He had determined that he needed to grow to be a chartered accountant in class itself however now the shortage of consideration for college students coming from containment zones or college students who’re COVID-19 optimistic, he’s uncertain if he’ll be capable of make it to the examination corridor.

“It’s clearly talked about within the SOPs that containment zone and COVID-19 optimistic college students are to not be allowed into the examination corridor, however how will they confirm this for therefore many college students? ICAI has not taken any step to conduct exams for such college students however has merely chosen to not allow them to sit for the exams. It’s a violation of scholars’ proper to equality. In all different exams, whether or not JEE, NEET or CLAT, there have been separate preparations for such college students,” Gehlot stated.

Travelling lengthy distance amidst a well being disaster is an added stress. “Many college students have been allotted centres at a distance of greater than two hours. It is extremely dangerous for college students to make use of public transportation and lots of college students can’t afford non-public transportation – that too for eight days,” he stated. The a number of exams that the scholars have to seem for are unfold over the course of 18 days.

College students suggest options

“The ICAI may accomplish that many issues to make life for college students in containment zones simpler. They might make separate preparations for them, conduct a web based examination, give an additional try to these college students who can’t seem for the exams in November or present secure, sanitised transport services to those that can’t journey on their very own,” Gehlot stated.

Abhinav, a closing 12 months pupil of CA is one other whose examination was due in Could however was postponed to November. He had chosen to check CA as a result of he believed that he had an eye fixed for element when it got here to monetary transactions and frauds.

Nonetheless, he’s afraid that he won’t be able to take a seat for the exams if, “he exams optimistic for COVID-19, his residence falls into the containment zone, he demonstrates any signs of COVID-19 on the examination centre,” he stated. He’ll then mechanically be shifted to seem for the following try i.e. Could 2021, additional delaying his skilled objectives by one other six months.

Picture: Particular Association

He stated that as a result of these exams are extraordinarily necessary, college students will seem for them no matter their well being circumstances, which could end result within the unfold of the coronavirus.

Yearly, greater than 4 lakh college students seem for CA exams. “Even when 5% of them get COVID-19 i.e. 24,000 college students roughly and contemplating that their mother and father (two individuals) may also take a look at optimistic due to them, a complete of 72,000 individuals would get the illness and contemplating the present loss of life charge of 1.6%, it might end in 1,152 casualties. I don’t suppose an examination is well worth the lives of 1,152 individuals,” he stated.

“Another try needs to be provided to the affected college students in December, January or February as an alternative of shifting their careers to Could 2021 immediately,” he stated. He additionally stated that the ICAI administration has not been paying any heed to requests on the helpline.

College students concern psychological stress, despair

Gehlot additionally stated that he had been getting ready for these exams for the final one 12 months – and if he’s unable to take a seat for them, it should trigger additional anxiousness and psychological stress to him.

Picture: Particular Association

Azra is one other pupil who fears that this uncertainty would possibly result in added stress. “College students lacking this examination will lose six valuable months of their profession. For many of us, this may have enormous monetary implications as effectively. Additionally, for previous course college students Could 2021 is the final try. So, lacking the November cycle will depart us with just one final shot on the diploma,” she stated.

Exposing relations to an infection

Hailing from Navi Mumbai, Azra lives together with her mother and father who’re over the age of 55 and a grandfather who’s over 85 years previous.

She is afraid that travelling for the examination would possibly put her and ultimately her household prone to contracting the coronavirus. “I’m a CA closing previous course pupil with solely 4 papers pending. So, that is mainly a do-or-die scenario for me, actually,” she stated.

The examination centre that she has been allotted is about 30 kilometres away from her home. She is afraid that she won’t be able to afford the day by day commute, given the truth that she belongs to a decrease earnings household. “I’ll have to vary two buses and a cab and spend two hours travelling (a technique) as a result of 30 kms in Mumbai isn’t a simple distance to navigate. Additionally taking a direct cab will price a minimal of Rs 1,000 a day because the centre is outdoors metropolis limits and solely intercity cabs ply. How is somebody from a decrease monetary background supposed to fulfill these bills?” she stated, and recommended that the exams both be performed on-line or postponed to January or February.

Security issues

Tanvi is a CA pupil from Mumbai who lives with retired mother and father. Describing the problem, she stated, “The issue merely put is security, or the shortage of it.” She stated that the centres would wish correct sanitisation each single day, however the college students are uncertain of the ICAI will observe these tips strictly. “College students are scared that they’ve higher probabilities of contracting COVID-19 and it doesn’t appear to be a good trade-off for a level, which we could or could not get.”

The answer that ICAI has offered is to let college students ‘choose’ out of those exams and carry ahead all advantages to the Could 2021 cycle. However college students don’t agree. “This prolongs all the things by 6 extra months. ICAI mainly has mentally exhausted its college students by constantly suspending exams on the nth hour losing college students’ time loads,” Tanvi stated.

She means that the ICAI ought to take the scholars’ issues severely. “ICAI ought to realise that these are unprecedented instances. They can’t merely brush this off as college students being unprepared. Each try you’ll have college students like that. They don’t come on Twitter and beg to be heard,” she stated.

One of many posters being circulated by CA college students on-line. Picture: Particular Association

“Since throughout our examination there can be varied factors of contact (reply papers, query papers, attendance register, corridor ticket, and so forth.) there may be an elevated likelihood of an infection. Possibly take a few months and actually make good preparations with far more centres if on-line exams are ‘unattainable’?” she stated.

A troublesome path, lengthy journey

Siddhi, who hails from Telangana, is a devoted CA closing 12 months pupil. Whereas pursuing an undergraduate diploma from St Francis School for Ladies on the similar time, Siddhi realised, “This [CA] course requires immense multi-tasking as a pupil has to stability their school, teaching, full time three-year internship and research.”

She believes that even after going by way of such a troublesome course of to achieve this stage, the difficulties haven’t ended as a result of the exams are being performed in the midst of a pandemic. “If somebody misses the examination, it’ll be a waste of humongous effort for them,” she stated.

Questioning the nation’s healthcare system, she stated,“ With COVID instances rising day by day and lots of states foreseeing a second or third wave, I wish to know is the Indian healthcare ready to accommodate extra instances if these exams happen now?” She can be afraid that she would possibly expose her grandmother, who’s 82 years of age, to the virus.

She additionally accused the administration of bias. “The members of the ICAI not too long ago bought extensions for submitting returns underneath GST. However when college students enchantment to them on the identical floor, our calls for go unheard,” she claimed.

The examination sample can be questionable, she added. “The inter and closing exams are divided into two teams with 4 papers every. In contrast to the diploma examination, if I select to not write the examination due to signs or as a result of I come from a containment zone, say after three papers, I should repeat all of the exams within the subsequent try.”

She stated that the CA exams can’t be in contrast with NEET or UPSC exams, which had prompted enormous nationwide protests as a result of they have been a one-day affair.

Picture: Particular Association

What does ICAI say? 

In a press launch, the ICAI stated, “Announcement is being issued to assuage any issues of the candidates and to guarantee them that the November 2020 CA Examinations can be held as scheduled in a secure ambiance.” A writ petition was filed by some college students earlier than the Supreme Courtroom, which was disposed of by the court docket on November 4.

“Through the course of listening to, ICAI knowledgeable the Hon’ble Courtroom that it had verified the place from the involved examination centres and was knowledgeable by the stated examination centres that they don’t seem to be falling in any containment zones. The Hon’ble Courtroom was additionally knowledgeable that clarification had been obtained from the involved examination centres and none of them have been declared as covid-care [COVID-19] services,” the discharge stated.

“As regards request for isolation rooms, the Hon’ble Courtroom was knowledgeable that that is neither attainable nor fascinating in bigger curiosity of different candidates, workers and so forth. to permit individuals exhibiting covid [COVID-19] signs to enter the examination centres. Concerning additional time to be offered for writing examination, it was clarified that it being knowledgeable examination, no additional time needs to be offered because the query papers are set as per the time required to reply the identical,” it said.

It additional stated that on-line exams weren’t attainable. “ICAI has knowledgeable the Courtroom that on-line examinations should not attainable as the topics are descriptive in nature. The Hon’ble Supreme Courtroom was additionally knowledgeable that ICAI has already opened greater than 600 centres in 200 new cities with standby buffer centres in case of emergency to accommodate candidates in unexpected conditions,” it learn.

Siddhi stated, referring to the press launch, “The SC verdict requested ICAI to difficulty a press launch resolving pupil queries. The press launch was insufficient and solely dismissed our queries moderately than offering an answer!”


Supply hyperlink